I buy the Smuckers brand all natural peanut butter the ingredients are: peanuts (that's all). You have to be very careful a lot of the "natural peanut butter" contain other ingredients. The big offender I found was the Jiffy Natural Smooth. They advertise that it dosent require stiring. I believe this given the fact that the ingredients are almost exactly the Sam a standard peanut butter....fucking marketing.
Read the labels before you put the jar in your basket/cart
This is what I eat. It is so fucking good. Sometimes I just crave it and have to go take a scoop out of the jar. I am a peanut butter and jelly eating machine and this is the shit.